Storage and Transportation

The U.S. inventory of spent nuclear fuel (SNF) from commercial nuclear power plants is estimated to reach approximately 135,000 metric tons by mid-century. Sandia performs research and development (R&D) to support the safe management and integration of the continued storage and transportation of commercial SNF, safeguards and security considerations, and the potential impacts from alternate/advanced fuel cycles.

We leverage state-of-the-art capabilities within the U.S. national lab complex, industry, academia, and international collaborators to provide experimental, analytical and modeling tools, data, and analyses to the U.S. government to make decisions and communicate the safety of long-term storage and subsequent transportation of SNF.

Sandia will continue to develop and perform cutting-edge testing and analysis to support an integrated solution to storage, transportation, and disposal challenges, with consideration of multiple clients and stakeholders.  

Areas of focused research and development include:

  • Storage research and development
  • Transportation research and development

Storage Research and Development

Sandia’s storage R&D is focused on the performance and integrity of spent fuel and canisters in dry cask storage systems (DCSSs). We perform R&D to support the development of the technical basis for the extended storage and transportation of commercial SNF. The products are peer-reviewed research reports to be used by policy and regulatory decision makers. 

Spent Fuel Integrity

Sandia, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), and the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) have a decades-long collaboration to obtain data on how SNF ages while in long-term storage. Data obtained from this collaboration is being used to develop aging management plans to mitigate potential changes to the spent fuel over time to better ensure that the fuel maintains its integrity for as long as needed.

Sandia plays a leadership role in the DOE/EPRI High Burnup Spent Fuel Confirmatory Data Project. The DOE/EPRI High Burnup Confirmatory Data Project will store a loaded commercially licensed cask in the same conditions that a typical cask would experience. The data obtained after 10 years of dry storage will indicate if there might be hydride re-orientation, which would have a significant effect on reducing the strength of the cladding. It is believed that the conditions that cause hydride reorientation will not develop in the loaded casks. This test will be instrumental in helping to prove that hypothesis.

Storage System Integrity

Sandia performs R&D on stress corrosion cracking (SCC) of canisters in DCSS. Sandia’s R&D evaluates the three concurrent conditions required to cause stress corrosion cracking.

1. Susceptible Material

We are investigating the formation and effects of SCC by:

  • Evaluating a stainless-steel canister’s internal stresses that may exist from the fabrication of the canister, particularly in and around welds and heat-affected zones, which are most susceptible to SCC
  • Evaluating via sampling and analysis of dusts collected from the surface of in-service storage canisters, and by experimental testing of brine stabilities under canister surface conditions
  • Evaluating typical weld samples
  • Evaluating by characterizing weld residual stresses in a full diameter canister mockup, manufactured using identical procedures as in-service storage canister

2. Aggressive Environment

To test the effects of aggressive environments, several utilities provided dust samples from loaded canisters currently in service. Chloride salts, which can cause SCC, were found on canisters near the ocean. Sandia is in the process of collecting additional samples to determine:

  • Deposited salt compositions
  • Salt loads and compositions as a function of canister surface location and surface temperature
  • How those salt compositions change in representative temperatures and humidities
  • What environmental conditions are needed to support or stop corrosion and potential cracking

3. Tensile Stress

To evaluate tensile stress, which leads to expansion of materials, we used a full-diameter canister manufactured using identical procedures as in-service storage canister. Work is ongoing to understand incubation, pitting, transition from pit to crack, then crack growth rate, as well as what conditions lead to corrosion stifling. Also, monitoring and aging management practices at storage sites will be important to confirm storage system performance during extended service.

Thermal Hydraulic Experiments and Analysis of Dry Cask Systems

The Nuclear Energy Work Complex (NEWC) is comprised of two separate work sites, the CYlindrical BoiLing (CYBL) facility and the Surtsey test center. CYBL is an enclosed, three-story, climate-controlled building that can support open and confined space testing, such as dry storage system thermal-hydraulics and simulated cladding fires during spent fuel pool loss of coolant accidents. It is constructed around a robust stainless-steel tank that was originally built to test flooded reactor containment concepts. The Surtsey location includes large open areas for outdoor testing, smaller buildings for indoor testing, a blast pad for high-energy tests, and on-site facilities for developing test components (e.g., machining, electronics, fabrication, construction, videography, data acquisition). The NEWC facilities provide large-scale experimental capabilities focused on high-quality and real-world testing of nuclear power components, including prototypic spent fuel assemblies and dry storage systems. Conditions for testing include steady state and severe transients up to and including destruction of test assemblies. Testing at NEWC has supported technology development and addressed safety basis issues associated with extreme operating environments and postulated severe accidents for the DOE, NRC, and industry.

Commercial spent fuel dry storage systems utilize different drying cycles to remove water prior to storage. Given the lack of data suitable for the model validation of drying processes, carefully designed investigations that incorporate relevant physics and well-controlled boundary conditions are being developed to supplement existing field data. The insight gained through these investigations is expected to support the technical basis for the continued safe storage of SNF into long term operations.

DCSS for SNF are designed to provide a confinement barrier that prevents the release of radioactive material, maintain SNF in an inert environment, provide radiation shielding, and maintain subcritical conditions. The potential for stress corrosion cracks (SCCs) in canister walls is a concern for DCSS for SNF. Some of the canisters in these systems are backfilled to significant pressures to promote heat rejection via internal convection. This testing seeks to directly quantify the flow rate and aerosol transmission through engineered representations for SCCs under conditions of interest for SNF storage.

Temperature drives nearly all primary fuel degradation mechanisms under normal conditions. Therefore, accurate models are needed over a highly dynamic range of conditions to predict fuel performance. Current tests involve a dry storage cask simulator, which is instrumented with a geometrically prototypic BWR fuel assembly with heater rods to mimic the decay heat of spent nuclear fuel and is designed to validate various thermal-hydraulic codes, such as Ansys Fluent, STAR-CCM+, and COBRA SFS.

Transportation Research and Development

The U.S. inventory of SNF is currently stored at ~70 locations around the country. It must eventually be safely transported to a permanent disposal site and/or consolidated interim storage locations. Therefore, it is important to understand if and how transport could damage the spent fuel and/or storage canisters and transportation casks.

Sandia created and led an international team to evaluate safety implications of transporting spent nuclear fuel across the world. The team measured shocks and vibrations experienced by surrogate spent nuclear fuel during normal rail, barge, and truck transport using a highly instrumented storage/transportation cask. The analysis of the data collected revealed that the stresses the cladding experiences due to vibration and shock during transportation are far below yield and fatigue limits.

Geoff Freeze

(505) 284-8594

gafreez@sandia.gov

Sylvia Saltzstein

(505) 844-0651

sjsaltz@sandia.gov